Jennifer Dunn and Sheena Hume promoted to Senior Deputy Clerk
Ampersand is pleased to announce the promotion of Jennifer Dunn and Sheena Hume to the newly created role of Senior Deputy Clerk.
The Senior Deputy Clerk role has been designed to support the strategic and day-to-day management of Ampersand’s practice groups. Jennifer and Sheena will work closely with the Head Clerk and the wider clerking team to oversee the practices of our members, and to make sure that solicitors and clients continue to receive the high standard of service for which Ampersand is known.
Both have been central to the Clerking team as Deputy Clerks, and their promotion reflects the experience, judgement and commitment they bring to members and instructing solicitors alike.
Alan Moffat, Head Clerk and Practice Manager, said:
“I’m delighted to congratulate Jennifer and Sheena on their well-deserved promotions. Both have made an outstanding contribution to the Stable and are trusted by members and solicitors across all of our practice areas. These new roles recognise that contribution and give us greater capacity to manage our practice groups strategically, while keeping the responsive, personal service our clients rely on at the heart of everything we do. I look forward to working with them both as we continue to grow.”
Please join us in congratulating Jennifer and Sheena on their new roles.
Tony Jones KC called to the Scottish Bar and joins Ampersand Advocates
One of Scotland’s most experienced civil solicitor advocates, Tony Jones KC, has been called to the Bar and joined Ampersand Advocates, bringing more than 35 years of disputes experience in professional negligence and construction.
Tony Jones KC was called to the Scottish Bar on 6th November 2026 and has joined Ampersand Advocates.
Tony Jones KC
Tony joins the Bar from Brodies LLP, where he was a partner from 2018. He became a solicitor advocate with extended rights of audience in the civil courts in 1999 and, in 2017, became only the fifth civil solicitor advocate in Scotland to take silk.
His practice centres on professional negligence and construction – both areas in which he was accredited by the Law Society of Scotland as a specialist while in practice as a solicitor advocate. He also acts in commercial disputes, company, insolvency and restructuring, real estate litigation, product liability, professional regulatory work, public inquiries and fatal accident inquiries, and trusts and succession, and has experience in alternative dispute resolution.
Tony has appeared in the Court of Session (Inner and Outer House), the Sheriff Appeal Court, the sheriff courts, before professional disciplinary bodies and at courts martial. He has acted for and against professional firms in high-value claims, including Commercial Court proofs and debates on liability, quantum and prescription.
Chambers & Partners 2025 describes him as “confident, super knowledgeable and commercially pragmatic. He distils the situation down with ease and then presents the best options to the client.”
Alongside his practice, Tony sits on the Disciplinary Panel of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland (ICAS) and is Treasurer of the Society of Writers to His Majesty’s Signet (WS Society). For many years he sat on the Law Society of Scotland’s Rights of Audience Committee and taught advocacy on the Society’s rights of audience course. He is also a trustee of the Royal Scots (The Royal Regiment) War Memorial Trust and Scottish Veterans Residences, following 14 years’ service as a Territorial Army officer. He was called to the Bar of England and Wales (Middle Temple) in 2022.
Tony Jones KC said: “After more than 25 years appearing in court as a solicitor advocate, joining the Bar is a natural next step. I’m delighted to be joining Ampersand, and I look forward to working with solicitors and clients across Scotland on professional negligence, construction and commercial disputes.”
Isla Davie KC, Stable Director at Ampersand Advocates, said: “Tony brings a depth of courtroom and commercial experience that few new members can match. His reputation in professional negligence and construction makes him a natural fit for Ampersand, and we’re very pleased to welcome him to the stable.”
Instructions
Tony is available for instruction now. To instruct him, contact the Ampersand clerks on 0131 260 5674 or ampersandclerks@advocates.org.uk, or view his full profile here.
Success in the Inner House for Ampersand’s Paul Reid KC
Ampersand’s Paul Reid KC, leading David Welsh, represented the Scottish Ministers in a successful appeal against decisions of the Scottish Information Commissioner. Counsel were instructed by the Scottish Government Legal Directorate.
The decisions concerned freedom of information requests for material given to the James Hamilton investigation, which examined whether Nicola Sturgeon had breached the Scottish Ministerial Code in relation to meetings involving Alex Salmond.
The First Division agreed that the Commissioner had set the bar too high when weighing the risk that disclosure could identify a protected individual. Publication does not have to confirm someone’s identity outright. The court held that the test is whether it would give rise to a real or substantial risk of that person being identified.
The ruling will be an important reference point wherever freedom of information duties meet contempt of court and the risk of “jigsaw identification”.
The full Opinion of the court, delivered by the Lord President, can be accessed here.
Court of Session rules on prescription and collateral warranties in Aberdeen hotel cladding claim
Court of Session rules on prescription and collateral warranties in Aberdeen hotel cladding claim
Lord Richardson has issued his opinion following a second debate in the case of Leonardo Hotel Management (UK) Limited v Galliford Try Building 2014 Limited and others [2026] CSOH 103; another decision on prescription in the context of alleged cladding defects.
Sean White appeared for the pursuer, led by Tim Young and instructed by Morton Fraser MacRoberts LLP.
The opinion covers a good deal of ground for construction practitioners:
Collateral warranties – The Court was tasked with considering whether each of the first and second defender’s collateral warranties provided them with ‘equivalent rights of defence’ to those with which they would be afforded under the original construction contract and architect’s appointment, respectively. The wording of the relevant clauses each contained a variation of wording considered by the Inner House in British Overseas Bank Nominees Limited v Stewart Milne Group Limited, in which equivalent rights of defence were found to exist and Legal & General Assurance v Halliday Fraser Munro, in which no equivalent rights of defence were found to exist. Having considered these authorities, Lord Richardson determined that the wording of each of the collateral warranties in the present case could be interpreted as conveying equivalent rights of defence, which extended to computation of the relevant prescriptive periods. (Paras [96] to [109]).
The Opinion offers guidance to practitioners on the Court’s approach to contractual interpretation in this context, in circumstances where the wording of the collateral warranty sits somewhere between that previously considered by the Inner House of the Court of Session.
Section 11(3) Lord Richardson revisited the conclusion reached in his previous Opinion ([2024] CSOH 43), agreeing that the Inner House decision in Tilbury Douglas v Ove Arup and Partners had developed the principles set down by the Supreme Court in Gordon’s Trustees v Campbell Riddell Breeze Paterson LLP. The Inner House in that case had applied those principles to a provider rather than a recipient of services, concluding that the creditor had sufficient awareness of loss having been sustained solely because it was aware of the fact that the fixed-price contract had been concluded, in terms of which it would subsequently be obliged to incur expenditure in relation to re-design and consequent delays. Lord Richardson found the circumstances of the present case to be analogous to those in Tilbury Douglas, whereby entering into the lease, rather than a fixed term contract, was the time at which the pursuer’s losses were “locked in” as a result of the repairing obligations which it had undertaken. (Paras [116] to [127]).
The Opinion bears to reaffirm that the harsh outcome for pursuers in cases such as David T Morrison v ICL Plastics Limited will apply in the context of tenant’s repairing obligations.
Section 6(4) A significant focus of the debate was on whether the pursuer’s pleadings disclosed relevant averments to invoke section 6(4) of the 1973 Act. In this regard, the Court required to consider the recent comments of Lord Malcolm in Tilbury Douglas on whether conduct as ‘everyday’ as providing services and accepting payment under a contract could be relied upon for the purposes of section 6(4). Aligning himself with the views of Lord Sandison in Batchelor v Opel Automobile GmbH, Lord Richardson considered that the statutory language of section 6(4) did not provide for any such restriction on the type of conduct which might be relied upon and that the obiter comments of Lord Malcolm went no further than to query whether generic conduct which was apparently unrelated to any relevant error on the part of the creditor fell within the scope of section 6(4). Lord Richardson found, in any event, that the conduct relied upon in the present case could be distinguished from the sort of ‘everyday’ conduct contemplated by Lord Malcolm as the pursuer relied upon a course of conduct by the defenders which included a physical concealment of defects. The pursuer’s averments in this regard were therefore held to be relevant for proof. (Paras [128] to [153]).
The Opinion offers reassurance to practitioners that section 6(4) will not be applied in such a restrictive way as had been hinted at in previous authorities and may continue to be relied upon by pursuers faced with prescription arguments where there has been a genuine error as to the existence of defects, induced by the words or conduct of a debtor.
Section 11(2) The Court was also asked to determine the relevancy of the second defender’s averments in response to a prescription plea taken against it by the third party. The question for the Court was whether the alleged misrepresentation relied upon by the second defender was a ‘continuing act, neglect or default’ for the purposes of section 11(2) of the 1973 Act. The third party sought to argue, under reference to the Supreme Court’s decision in Cramaso LLP v Viscount Reidhaven’s Trustees, that a misrepresentation ceased to become a continuing act, neglect or default at the time it was acted upon by a representee. Lord Richardson rejected this argument, considering it to have been misconceived. His Lordship noted that the Court in Cramaso was not considering the nature of misrepresentation through the prism of section 11(2) and, in any event, rejected the idea that reliance on a representation might necessarily act as a bar on that representation being further reasonably relied upon by a representee.
The defenders’ and third party’s motions for absolvitor and dismissal were refused and a proof before answer allowed, albeit with certain averments excluded from probation.
The Opinion of Lord Richardson can be viewed here.
Ampersand Advocates shines in outstanding Chambers & Partners UK Bar 2027 Rankings
Ampersand Advocates has been ranked in twelve practice areas in the Chambers & Partners UK Bar 2027 guide, with six in Band 1, and 41 of our members hold 94 individual rankings between them across 20 practice areas.
All twelve of the set rankings we held in last year’s guide are retained, and one has moved up.
Civil Liberties & Human Rights rises from Band 2 to Band 1, joining Clinical Negligence, Personal Injury, Planning & Environment, Public & Fatal Accident Inquiries and Tax. Maria Maguire KC is ranked as a Star Individual in both Clinical Negligence and Personal Injury, and Graham Primrose KC is a Star Individual in Personal Injury.
The rankings are based on interviews with the solicitors and clients who instruct us, and we are grateful to everyone who took the time to speak to Chambers. Their comments, a selection of which appear below, are the best measure of the work our members do.
Set rankings
Practice areas and ranked members
Administrative & Public Law – Band 2
Chambers Review: A “wide variety of counsel with different specialisms”
“If you have a contentious IP case, he is first name on the list.” – on Usman Tariq KC, Intellectual Property
“Amelia is brilliantly clever, a pleasure to deal with and incredibly responsive.” – on Amelia Mah, Intellectual Property
Star Individuals
Maria Maguire KC (Clinical Negligence and Personal Injury) and Graham Primrose KC (Personal Injury) are ranked as Star Individuals, the highest individual ranking Chambers awards.
Up and Coming
Five of our juniors are recognised as Up and Coming: Ayla Iridag (Administrative & Public Law, Civil Liberties & Human Rights and Personal Injury), Scott Clair (Civil Liberties & Human Rights, Professional Discipline and Professional Negligence), Amelia Mah (Intellectual Property), Mary Ellen Stewart (Public & Fatal Accident Inquiries) and Shane Dundas (Public & Fatal Accident Inquiries).
Breadth of practice
Many of our members are ranked across several areas. Usman Tariq KC holds nine rankings, Paul Reid KC and Ross G. Anderson KC six each, and Michael Way five. Ross, who took silk this year, is ranked in Band 1 in five practice areas: Commercial Dispute Resolution, Company, Real Estate Litigation, Restructuring/Insolvency and Tax.
Clerking
Our clerking team, led by Advocates’ Clerk Alan Moffat, is again singled out by those who instruct us.
“All of the clerks are very good and responsive. Head clerk Alan Moffat is particularly good. He comes to me with solutions rather than leaving it with me to deal with.” – Personal Injury
“Alan Moffat is one of the go-to people if you need to get a counsel, and he is always able to provide good advice on who would be suitable for a matter.” – Commercial Dispute Resolution
“The clerks will bend over backwards to accommodate you and help you find counsel, even in challenging situations.” – Clinical Negligence
Congratulations to every member recognised this year, and thank you to our clients and instructing solicitors for their continued trust.
Ampersand Advocates continues its reputation as one of Scotland’s leading stable for excellence across the civil Bar. Ampersand stands out for its depth, versatility, and advocacy excellence.
The full rankings and editorial are available on the Chambers & Partners website. To instruct any of our members, contact the clerks on 0131 260 5674 or at ampersandclerks@advocates.org.uk.
Craig Murray – Petitioner and Reclaimer for Judicial Review of the Terrorism Act 2000 (Proscribed Organisations) (Amendment) Order 2025 [2026] CSIH 45
The First Division today issued its Opinion in the petition by Craig Murray for judicial review of the Terrorism Act 2000 (Proscribed Organisations) (Amendment) Order 2025.
The case relates to a proscription decision taken by the UK Government.
Today’s decision of the Inner House relates to the process for challenging that decision, and in particular the impact of related proceedings in England & Wales on the petition for judicial review in Scotland.
Graham MacIver and Chris Stephen acted for the Advocate General for Scotland, led by Mark Lindsay KC of Axiom Advocates.
Mark Boni and Tony Convery acted for the petitioner, led by Aidan O’Neill KC of 1Six Chambers, and instructed by Halliday Campbell WS.